I would keep the first one. You have bonded with her. I received a greenish AG15 last fall. I can't bring myself to swap her, as another doll to replace her just wouldn't be her. Once a doll enters this house they are here to stay, unless one of my Granddaughters "needs the doll". Out of the 5 GD's that have the dolls, 2 of them are AG fanatics.